Reducing cost of public housing: Some policy suggestions

The drastic increase in the cost of public housing over the past 30 years has caused a financial squeeze for many Singaporeans, particularly young couples who desire to own their own homes, and families forced to downgrade because of financial difficulties.

The drastic increase in the cost of public housing over the past 30 years has caused a financial squeeze for many Singaporeans, particularly young couples who desire to own their own homes, and families forced to downgrade because of financial difficulties.

A three-room resale flat in the prime area of Tiong Bahru used to cost just $6,000 back in 1975. Now three room flats in that area are selling for as much as $322,000! This 5,266% price increase is simply mind-boggling! It has far outpaced inflation and increases in salaries over the past 30 years.

The cash over valuation (COV) that buyers are now having to pay is also shooting through the roof, and threatens to get even higher when the casino resorts open next year.

National development minister Mah Bow Tan claimed that one third of resale flats are “transacted at or below” COV. This claim is almost laughable if you ask any home buyer or real estate agent.

Continue reading “Reducing cost of public housing: Some policy suggestions”

Let’s return to the Malaysia Cup

The S-League has proven to be quite a failure, to the point where the only people who watch it are those who have placed bets on the matches. It’s no point continuing to pour money into a losing venture. A little bit of compromise and humble-pie eating will be in order to get our teams back into the Malaysia Cup.

I like Aymeric Lim’s letter to the Straits Times Forum on Saturday 17 October. Like many Singaporeans, he called for Singapore to return to the Malaysia Cup football league.

He offered a new suggestion which I hadn’t heard before: Instead of returning as the Singapore national team, our current clubs in S-League could go in separately on their own. There could also be stricter caps on the number of foreign players allowed on each team. This could dispel the Malaysians’ fear that our over-funded national team will overwhelm their state teams and malu them again. I think the Malaysian teams and fans will welcome the competition. I’m sure sponsors on both sides will  definitely support it.

Continue reading “Let’s return to the Malaysia Cup”

Govt concedes argument with WP and Singaporeans

The opposition MPs in Hougang and Potong Pasir, who have been serving their residents for 18 years and 25 years respectively, have a far more distinguished track record of “concrete actions” serving their residents than the Johnny-come-lately PAP challengers, who are very good at plastering their faces all over the ward and claiming credit for things they never did.

Since the ill-advised announcement by the so-called PAP “grassroots advisers” of Hougang and Potong Pasir about the Lift Upgrading Programme (LUP) in the two opposition-held wards, the Minister for National Development has had to answer three letters to the Straits Times to justify their stand on the issue. Two of those letters were in response to Workers’ Party leaders Low Thia Khiang and Sylvia Lim, and one was to a public-spirited Singaporean, Muhammad Yusuf Osman.

In his latest letter (copied below), the spokesman of National Development Minister Mah Bow Tan wrote: “We do not expect the Workers’ Party to accept these basic facts, and we will agree to disagree.”

In saying this, the Minister is basically conceding that his argument holds no water, and he has no more points to add that could better justify the PAP’s politically-motivated stand.

Continue reading “Govt concedes argument with WP and Singaporeans”

WP rebuts Minister on lift upgrading

This shows the respect the government has for the people’s choice of Member of Parliament, who is vested with the Constitutional mandate to represent the constituency.

The Workers’ Party’s rebuttal published in the Straits Times today.

————–

I refer to the reply from the Minister for National Development’s Press Secretary on Tuesday entitled: “Ministry: MP Low wrong on lift upgrading”. I am responding to it as Mr Low Thia Khiang is currently out of town.

MND states that HDB’s letter published last Friday “should be read in conjunction with” the Minister’s earlier explanations to the media. This impliedly acknowledges that the reason given by HDB to Mr Muhd Yusuf Osman, who had pointedly asked why protocol seemed to be ignored when HDB worked with the unelected candidates in opposition wards to announce LUP plans rather than with the elected MPs, does not stand up to scrutiny.
It is not disputed that the LUP is a government programme. After all, it is to rectify a design flaw in public housing which does not cater for an ageing society. Given this imperative, the public interest should trump politics.

Mr Low’s letter was not about wanting credit for the programme. He has stated that he is prepared to work with the government’s appointees for the benefit of his constituents, and indeed has met the grassroots advisor several times over many months to give input on the LUP plans for Hougang.

It was HDB’s unjustifiable answer to Mr Yusuf – that the grassroots advisor was more appropriate than the MP to announce the LUP plans because he was able to gather residents’ input and marshal support for the plans – which compelled Mr Low’s response. HDB should have just given the real reason in its letter and not beat around the bush.

MND’s letter goes further to state that the LUP is funded from budget surpluses which Opposition MPs are not responsible for generating. However, the budget surpluses are hardly the effort of the government alone, as they include significant contributions from the public through taxes, levies and stamp fees, which the government simply reaps.

Finally, MND also appears to interpret the General Elections as an event where the only outcome which matters is who forms the government. This shows the respect the government has for the people’s choice of Member of Parliament, who is vested with the Constitutional mandate to represent the constituency.

SYLVIA LIM (Ms)
CHAIRMAN,
WORKERS’ PARTY

New Information Minister disappoints

I am disappointed to learn that Acting Minister for Information Lui Tuck Yew has upheld his predecessor’s ban on Martyn See’s film, Zahari’s 17 Years.

Said ZahariWhen RAdm(NS) Lui Tuck Yew was appointed Acting Minister for Information, Communications and the Arts in April this year, News Radio 938 interviewed me to ask for my views on his appointment. I recall telling the journalist that I hoped Mr Lui would have the boldness to do things differently from his predecessor, Dr Lee Boon Yang, particularly in the area of political expression.

I am therefore very disappointed to learn that Mr Lui, who is also an MP for Tanjong Pagar together with MM Lee Kuan Yew, has upheld his uptight predecessor’s ban on Martyn See‘s film, Zahari’s 17 Years. The film is a documentary interview with former journalist Said Zahari, who was accused by the government of then-Prime Minister Lee Kuan Yew of being a communist, a violent revolutionary and a foreign agent, and detained without trial under the Internal Security Act for 17 years.

Continue reading “New Information Minister disappoints”

Mah to Low: Stay within your sandbox

The Minister for National Development has basically told Low Thia Khiang to stay within the confines of his town council and stop trying to manage the Lift Upgrading Programme.

In what is probably one of his most insulting and condescending statements to date, the Minister for National Development, though his taxpayer-funded press secretary, has basically told Opposition leader and Hougang MP Low Thia Khiang to stay within the confines of his town council and stop trying to manage the Lift Upgrading Programme (LUP), period.

Here are excerpts of what the press secretary to the Minister wrote in his Straits Times Forum letter today:

Continue reading “Mah to Low: Stay within your sandbox”

Low Thia Khiang: PAP is playing politics

Low Thia Khiang: I am prepared to work with anyone from the Government for the benefit of my constituents.

Workers’ Party secretary-general and MP for Hougang, Low Thia Khiang, has hit back at the PAP for playing politics with residents of opposition wards, and not respecting the will of the people. He decried the practice of the PAP’s unelected grassroots adviser leading the gathering and planning residents’ needs instead of the the elected MP.

Here is his letter published in the Straits Times today:

Continue reading “Low Thia Khiang: PAP is playing politics”

How PAP uses taxpayer-funded grassroots for political gain

Not many Singaporeans are aware of how much the taxpayer-funded grassroots have been used by the PAP for political gain.

Last week, Mr Eric Low and Mr Sitoh Yih Pin, the PAP MP-aspirants who lost to Workers’ Party’s Low Thia Khiang and SDA’s Chiam See Tong respectively in the last election, grabbed the limelight for themselves by announcing HDB’s decision to upgrade lifts in Potong Pasir and Hougang.

I had written an article questioning why HDB had informed the losing candidates in opposition wards of the upgrading plans.

A Straits Times forum letter writer, Mr Muhammad Yusuf Osman, said it best when he called for the mandate that the residents gave to the elected MPs to be respected. He asked: “Under what authority did both Mr (Eric) Low and Mr Sitoh (Yih Pin) act as advisers to the grassroots organisations, given that the People’s Association is a government statutory board and should work with the elected MPs of the constituencies?”

In response, HDB and People’s Association replied that “it is the Government’s practice to implement its national programmes for residents through advisers to grassroots organisations who are appointed by the Government to gather feedback from residents.”

They forgot to mention that these “advisers” are always PAP men, whether or not they won the election.

Not many Singaporeans are aware of how much the taxpayer-funded grassroots have been used by the PAP for political gain.

Here’s a quick run down:

Continue reading “How PAP uses taxpayer-funded grassroots for political gain”

Do your part to help disaster victims in Asia

We in Singapore are so fortunate to be shielded from all these calamities. Who says we have no natural resources? Our prized geographical position surrounded by calm seas and huge land masses is a natural resource in itself, that has contributed immensely to our economic development.

It is so heartbreaking to read about all the victims of natural disasters in the Philippines, Indonesia, India, Vietnam, Cambodia, Laos and Samoa all in the past one week. I can’t remember a week when so many disasters hit Asia at one go.

According to charity World Vision, 24.8 million people have been affected by floods in Philippines, Vietnam, Cambodia, Laos and India, and the earthquakes in Sumatra, Indonesia.

We in Singapore are so fortunate to be shielded from all these calamities. Who says we have no natural resources? Our prized geographical position surrounded by calm seas and huge land masses is a natural resource in itself, that has contributed immensely to our economic development.

To him whom much is given, much is also required. Let’s open up our hearts and our wallets to help our neighbours and fellow Asians.

Here’s what’s being done by just World Vision alone, and how you can help. I particularly appreciate the innovation of Child-Friendly Spaces that they have set up in Sumatra:

(From an email I received from World Vision)

Typhoon Ketsana and Typhoon Parma

Countries affected: Philippines, Vietnam, Cambodia and Laos.
Number of people affected: 3.9 million
Urgent need: US$2.65 million

  • World Vision Philippines has distributed relief goods to 15,670 people. Food items distributed include: 25 kilogram of rice, one packet of crackers, one packet of cheese cake bread, five litres of purified water, six packs of noodles, one kilogram of dried fish, one packet of coffee, one packet of sugar, 500 grams of iodised salt, one litre of cooking oil, four cans of corned beef, two cans of canned meat and five cans of sardines. Non-food items include two packets of sanitary napkins, three pieces of bath soaps, 2 sets of clothing, one mosquito net, one blanket, one plastic mat, one aluminium pot for cooking and 1 ladle for each family.
  • World Vision Philippines will provide assistance to 20,000 families, totalling 100,000 people in inaccessible areas in Marikina, Pasig, Cainta, and areas in Rizal province. Essential health services, food, water and other relief goods such as blankets and mats, as well as psychosocial support to about 800 affected children will continue to be provided over the next three months. Ongoing relief distributions and assessments are still being done to reach severely hit areas that have yet to receive aid.
  • For Typhoon Parma, World Vision Philippines is carrying out relief efforts in Zambales, Isabela and Cagayen. To date, more than 18,000 people have received relief packs and World Vision humanitarian relief experts are assessing the needs of the affected families.
  • World Vision Vietnam has distributed about US$30,000 worth of relief goods comprising rice, noodles, life vest, raincoats, torches and water. About 50,000 people will benefit from this initial response. World Vision Vietnam is also working alongside the government, UN agencies and other international NGOs to meet pressing needs such as food aid and shelter in the hardest hit provinces. In the longer term, World Vision Vietnam aims to help the affected children and families regain normalcy in their lives by helping them rebuild their livelihoods, and will incorporate plans to ensure that school children in affected project areas will receive continuity in their schooling as well.
  • World Vision Laos has distributed relief supplies such as food, water, candles, lighters and water purification tablets for some 2,755 families in 25 villages in Sepone district. World Vision aims to rebuild livelihoods by providing the affected communities with rice, seeds and livestock, in replacement of their loss. World Vision also plans to rebuild houses, set up rice banks and provide revolving loans.

To help them rebuild their lives, please click here

West Sumatra Quake

Areas affected: Padang and Padang Pariaman, Indonesia
Number of people affected: 600,000
Urgent need: US$2 million

  • About 60,000 people will benefit from World Vision’s relief efforts. World Vision Indonesia distributed 8,000 family kits and 4,250 children kits. These kits include items such as tarpaulins, sleeping mats, blankets, sarongs, sanitary napkins, toothbrushes and soap.
  • In Padang, World Vision delivered 2,000 collapsible water containers and 1,022 water containers while in Bungus Timor, World Vision has distributed 1,000 family kits and 2,000 water kits. World Vision will be sending another 16,000 water containers to Padang in the next few days.
  • Children are especially vulnerable psychologically to disasters, it is thus very important to give children a safe place where they can play, to provide them with sense of stability, routine, normalcy, to get them with their friends and away from the distress all around them. World Vision Indonesia will set up 13 Child-Friendly Spaces (4 in Padang and 9 in Pariaman) that will benefit some 1,953 children. Child-Friendly Spaces are designed to provide psychosocial support to children after a disaster or conflict.

To help them rebuild their lives, please click here

India Floods

Severely-affected areas: Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh
Number of people affected: 17.8 million in Karnataka, 2.5 million in Andhra Pradesh.
Urgent need: US$2 million

  • Floods in southern India have left 1.5 million homeless, 200 dead, and more than 200,000 homes destroyed. As a result, millions of farmers are suffering from failed harvests or crops destroyed by floodwaters. Massive food shortages resulting from flooding and drought are now impacting hundreds of millions of India’s civilians and setting back ongoing humanitarian work by years. World Vision India targets to meet the immediate needs of 180,000 flood survivors who have been driven from their homes into relief camps.
  • MehboobnagarAndhra Pradesh: World Vision India has distributed family packs consisting of tarpaulins, mosquito nets, buckets, plates, mugs, towels and bed sheets to 500 families. Some 3,000 families will be receiving food supplies including rice, lentils and oil in the next few days.
  • Premadhara, Andhra Pradesh: World Vision India distributed cooked food including rice, lentil curry and vegetables to 3,700 people.
  • Bijapur, Karnataka: World Vision India has distributed emergency food and non-food items for 185 families, and aims to distribute relief supplies to 2,600 families by Oct 9. Currently, many people are getting clean water from the reservoir that World Vision built through its Area Development Programme in previous years.

To help them rebuild their lives, please click here

—–

NOTE: I am not employed by World Vision, neither is this blog post requested by them nor endorsed by them. I prefer donating to World Vision because I find they are one of the most well organised and well run relief agencies operating in our region.

HDB should be neutral and stop playing politics

The HDB should stop letting itself become a political tool of the ruling PAP.

I am glad to learn that the opposition held wards of Hougang and Potong Pasir will finally be getting lift upgrading for their HDB blocks. This is a long overdue measure for the residents of the two constituencies, which have been strongholds of the opposition since 1991 and 1984 respectively.

Singaporeans will recall that on the eve of the polling day in 1997, then-Prime Minister Goh Chok Tong warned voters that opposition estates risked becoming “slums” if they continued voting out the PAP. Thus started a pattern of Third World pork barrel politics of the ruling PAP, which culminated in the 2006 election when PAP candidates Eric Low and Sitoh Yih Pin boasted that caretaker National Development Minister Mah Bow Tan had promised the two wards a total of $180 million for upgrading if residents voted for the PAP.

Fortunately, voters were too sophisticated and principled to fall for the PAP’s dirty tactics of using taxpayer money to advance their partisan political ends. Hougang and Potong Pasir voters proved that they could not be so easily swayed by money and election goodies by re-electing Mr Low Thia Khiang (Workers’ Party) and Mr Chiam See Tong (Singapore Democratic Alliance), the former with a record high winning margin.

Continue reading “HDB should be neutral and stop playing politics”